Personal Sour Cherry Pies for the Pie Party

July 6, 2011(updated on August 30, 2021)

tiny cherry pie

Recently, I found myself in the possession of a flat of cherries. Half sweet and half sour, I spent several days binging on cherries and finding various ways to put them up. I made jam with some of the sours, turned others into that no-cook sour cherry syrup and finally stashed four pitted cups in the freezer for another day.

I intended for that other day to be July 4th, but like so often in my life, I’m a day late (though hopefully not a dollar short). Scott and I had a couple friends over yesterday to swim in the pool on our roof and then dig into an indoor cookout. We had burgers, hot dogs, chicken sausage, potato salad, coleslaw, and grilled zucchini. It was quite a feast and in the activity of getting the rest of the meal made, I didn’t manage to make the pie (I also make five pints of dilly beans and nearly six pints of salsa yesterday, so it wasn’t as if I was lazing).

mini-cherry pies

But wanting to post a contribution to Shauna’s Pie Party, the first thing I did when I got home from work today was pull out my previously prepared pie crust to soften (I got so far as making the crust yesterday) and mix my defrosted cherries with a bit of sugar and flour.

One of the challenges that comes with making pie in my household is that my husband isn’t into fruit and so won’t help eat a pie (not even one as delicious as sour cherry). I am not capable of eating enough of any single pie in a timely fashion to make it worth making. So I determined to make small pies that could be frozen. I pondered forming them into jars like so many clever folk have done, but it’s canning season and I can’t spare the jars.


Instead, I used the large, six-cup muffin tin that Scott brought this to our marriage (it’s not a piece of equipment I would have bought on my own, but I find I use it all the time) and formed the pies into its wells. I tried to be creative in the ways I slit the top pastry, but by the time I was forming those lids, I’d overworked the dough and the gluten was making things too elastic to cut easily. I traded creativity for expediency and just cut slits.

They baked for approximately 40 minutes at 375 degrees. They bubbled beautifully and tasted like pure heaven (oh sour cherries, how did I survive my first 27 years without you?). A rough recipe is after the jump.

No ratings yet

Small Sour Cherry Pies


Basic Pie Dough Recipe (makes enough for a double pie crust)

  • 2 cups all purpose flour
  • 1/2 cup whole wheat flour
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 2 teaspoons sea salt
  • 2 sticks cold unsalted butter cut into cubes
  • 1/2 cup ice water

Sour Cherry Pie filling

  • 4 cups sour cherries pitted
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
  • 3 tablespoons butter

Egg Wash

  • 1 egg beaten
  • 1 tablespoon water


  • Combine the flours, sugar and salt in the bowl of a food processor. Pulse to combine. Add the cold butter cubes to the bowl and pulse until the butter is incorporated into the flours and largest bits look to be the size of peas.
  • Then, with the motor running, slowly stream the water into the bowl using the tube. Stop once you’ve added 1/4 cup of water and test the dough by squeezing it. If it sticks together, it’s done. You want it to just barely hold together.
  • Divide the dough in two and wrap it in plastic wrap or waxed paper. Store in the refrigerator for at least an hour before using. Overnight is fine too. The dough can also be frozen for up to a month.
  • If you don’t have a food processor, pie dough is still within your grasp. Combine the flours, sugar and salt in a large bowl and whisk together. Grate very cold butter using a box grater. When it’s all grated, combine with the flours in the bowl and work together using a pastry blender or your hands. Add water drop by drop until the dough comes together. Divide and store as recommended above.
  • Pit sour cherries and let sit for half an hour (I find that freezing and then defrosting the cherries is a really effective way to remove some of the excess liquid). Drain any liquid off. Add sugar and flour to cherries and stir. Set aside.
  • Roll out the pie crust and cut six rounds to fit your muffin tin or custard cups. Gently fit the rounds into the muffin wells. Evenly divide the cherry pie filling between the six cups. Top each small pie with 1/2 tablespoon butter.
  • Cut six smaller rounds of pie crust to use as lids. Cut vents to allow for steam (or use your creativity to devise something more aesthetically appealing). Brush pastry lids with egg wash on both sides. Fit onto pie bottoms and crimp to seal.
  • Bake at 375 degrees for 35-40 minutes, until tops are browned and the pie juices run thick and glossy.
  • Remove from oven and allow to cool for at least 10 minutes before removing from tins. Eat immediately or freeze on a cookie sheet.

Sharing is caring!

Posted in

Leave a comment & rate this recipe

If you enjoy this recipe, please do give it a star rating when you post a comment. Star ratings help people discover my recipes. Thank you!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

22 thoughts on "Personal Sour Cherry Pies for the Pie Party"

  • Oh my goodness, I would eat my screen if I could! I’ve made blueberry pies like this and have been waiting impatiently for tart cherries to be ready (so, so close!) to make these. Did you have any issues getting the ‘pie’ out of the muffin tin? I had to fuss with my blueberry ones a bit.

    Instead of slitting the tops, I use a small star shaped cookie cutter to make an opening in the center top and that’s the ‘vent’. It didn’t stretch out of shape too badly and didn’t bubble over.

    1. The muffin tins I have are non-stick, so they slipped right out. There’s so much butter in pie crust that I don’t think you should have a a problem, no matter the kind of pan.

  • “It’s canning season and I can’t spare the jars.” Great line! And exactly why we love you. I’m glad you’re freezing a few – do they ship well? 😉

  • Those look delicious! The fact that they’re personal sized makes them even more awesome 😀

  • My roommate (and general cohort in culinary goodness) is super particular about fruits she likes (strawberries, blackberries, mangoes, apples… that’s almost the end of the list). It looks like I need to indulge in some single serving pies so that if I want sour cherry pie (and I DO), I can have it.

  • These look fantastic!
    I’m still trying to wrap my head around someone not being all that into fruit. I love fruit so much that last night I dreamed that my husband and I had just made some new friends, and when we went to visit them we discovered they had an early pear tree in their yard covered in ripe pears. For the rest of the dream we picked pears and canned them in light syrup while listening to Tears for Fears. It was like I had an 80’s canning montage, mid-dream!

    1. He’ll eat pies that are filled with chocolate. Just not those that are fruity. He likes what he likes.

  • So cute! Now I’m craving pie for breakfast. I have been unsuccessful in finding sour cherries in my parts this year. Hoping for some this Saturday at the farmer’s market!

  • Wow, does this fall into the ‘why didn’t I think of that?’ catagory… Only 2 of us left in the house, so all desserts need to be small – or WE won’t be. I’ve already turned all the cake recipes into cupcakes, but stopped making pies unless we were having company…

    You may be my pie-loving Hubby’s new favorite person!

  • Oooh, I got some lovely ramekins for christmas that these little pies would fit perfectly in… And I still have a good two quarts of sour cherries from that flat in the freezer… now if only it wasn’t so hot I can’t bear the thought of turning the oven on!

  • I saw this recipe today and went home to make it! Turned out great. Thanks Marisa! I’ve been wondering what to do with that bag of frozen cherries in the freezer for weeks.