String beans are one of my favorite vegetables around. My idea of a perfect easy summer meal is a tangle of lightly steamed string beans, dressed with a bit of butter and salt, along side some scrambled eggs and a sliced tomato. A couple of summers ago, I ate that for dinner three or four times a week for at least a month. Of course, that was before I had to think of Scott’s likes and dislikes when making dinner and sadly, he is a string bean hater. So my perfect little meal has been relegated to a once-in-a-while, solo experience (however, it’s a trade-off I happily make for love).
Thing is, I still find myself buying string beans like they’re a four times a week vegetable, which becomes a problem when trying to keep the refrigerator eco-system balanced. That is where the dilly bean comes in. It’s a gentle, zippy little pickle that preserves my green beans for months to come (well, if they last that long) and maintains the dinnertime peace.
One thing to note about string beans. They are perfectly safe to can in a boiling water bath when you’re making pickles out of them. They are NOT safe to can without the brine unless you’re using a pressure canner. One of the few documented cases of botulism that occurred last year was because a family ate some poorly preserved green beans. So if you want to preserve your beans but you don’t want to pickle them, either get yourself a pressure canner or blanch and freeze them.
Enough safety warnings, on to the recipe…
Pickled Green Beans (aka Dilly Beans)
Ingredients
- 2 pounds green beans trimmed to fit your jars
- 2 1/2 cups apple cider vinegar 5%
- 2 1/2 cups water
- 2 tablespoons pickling or fine sea salt
- 4 teaspoons dill seed
- 2 teaspoons black peppercorns
- 1 teaspoon red chili flake
- 4 cloves garlic
Instructions
- Prepare a boiling water bath canner and 4 pint jars. Place 4 lids in a small pot of water and bring to a bare simmer.
- Wash and trim your beans so that they fit in your jar and leave about an inch of headspace. If you have particularly long beans, your best bet is to cut them in half, although by doing so, you do lose the visual appeal of having all the beans standing at attending.
- Combine vinegar, water, and salt in a medium saucepan and bring to a boil.
- Divide the dill seed, peppercorns, red chili flake, and garlic cloves evenly between the four jars.
- Pack the beans into the jars over the spices.
- Pour the boiling brine over the beans, leaving 1/2 inch headspace.
- Gently tap the jars on the counter to loosen any trapped air bubbles. For stubborn air pockets, use a chopstick to wiggle them free.
- Wipe rims, apply lids and rings, and process in a boiling water bath canner for 10 minutes.
- When time is up, remove jars from canner and place them on a folded kitchen towel to cool.
- Once jars are cool enough to handle, remove rings and test seals.
- Sealed jars can be stored on the pantry shelf for up to one year. Any unsealed jars should be refrigerated and eaten promptly.
- These beans want to hang out for a least two weeks before eating, to thoroughly develop their flavor.
Hi Marissa! I love your site and I’m new to canning. I have made a couple of batches of Dilly Beans this year and my family is hooked! My last batch however has tiny bubbles all over the beans. The jars sealed well. Do I need to be worried about these little bubbles? Also if I could bother you with the fact that my salsa, which is kind of thick, did the same thing. Is this a problem? Thanks so much for sharing your canning genius with us all 🙂
Don’t worry about the bubbles. They’ll eventually work their way up to the top of the jar.
Hi, I just made these beans yesterday and I put them in the fridge shortly after processing. I have active bubbles and a little bit of foam like they are carbonated. Does this mean they are bad? I checked the seals and they are pretty tight but they all have this. Are they ruined?
Thanks!
If they are bubbling they are fermenting. They’re no good. I have had this happen occasionally with pickles. Toss them or eat them soon. If they stink, definitely toss them. DEFINITELY don’t leave them in there with the rings on, they will burst.
I made these last night. I wish I could taste them right now! I’ve never had a dilly bean, so I hope I like them. I tried some with extra cayenne, some with tarragon, and some with extra garlic. Mine floated a bit, but I’m not sure how I could have prevented it- I packed those beans in there pretty tight! Thanks for the recipe!
Some of my jars have beans that have bubbles on them. Is this normal? I didn’t notice this the last time I put up a batch….
Hi – I made these pickles last night in 12oz jelly jars. I’m very novice to canning and am wondering if it’s a problem that the beans rose during process above the level of the brine to the point that they’re touching the lid. Are they still safe to eat or should I reprocess? What causes this issue?
Thanks!
I’ve got a batch of these processing in the boiler right now. We’ll see in a few weeks how they turned out!
We added fennel seeds, and about 1/2 t. dried lemon peel plus 2 chinese hot peppers and garlic in each jar. Turned out yummy and a great additional to salad nicoise with the beans, butter lettuce, tuna, hard eggs and tomato. Used some of the brine to make the vinaigrette, and added some fresh chopped fennel leaves (I believe they are a cousin of dill) to bring it together. Thanks for the inspiration!
I am looking for a recipe for pickled green beans that uses cinnamon sticks and is a little sweeter – no dill – my grandma used to make them and I can’t find the recipe. Anyone have any ideas?
I think your beans will taste fine. The dill you used was the dried leaf from the dill and is a little less potent than the seeds but still dill. I use the dried dill in dill pickles and when that is not availible I use the seeds.
Hope this helps.
Thank you so much for taking the time to answer my question. I guess we will find out in two weeks!
Dumb mistake: I used the herb, “Dill”, (from Trader’s Joes) as the dill in my Dilly Beans today. I didn’t read “dill seeds” in the recipe; I didn’t even know there was such a thing until I found this entry tonight on Food in Jars. What do you think they will taste like?
I just pickled some yellow wax beans,they look kinda wrinkled,where did I go wrong,what causes this?
Thanks!!
Nikki, there’s no way for me to be able to diagnose what may have gone wrong. Sometimes beans do get a little bit puckered in the canning process, so I imagine they’re probably fine.
I have been canning Dilly Green Beans for 20 years. They always look a little wrinkled for a few weeks. Put them away and in a few months they will swell up again and look great! Have patience………
I just made dilly beans but ended up using dilly herbs can I recan the beans and go to the store and get the dilly heads or dilly seeds to redo? And also what is the best way to eat the dilly beans is it heated up or just right out of the jar? I’ve never had them before and was wondering.
You don’t have to open the jars and recan. I call for dill seeds instead of dill weed because they hold up better during storage. However, the dill weed won’t make the jars bad, it may just make the brine a little murky. It’s mostly an aesthetic choice. You should just eat them straight out of the jar, like you would any other pickle. Don’t heat them up, they won’t be good that way.
THANK YOU so much for the information and setting my mind at ease about the ingredient I used instead of the one I should of used will know better next time.. Once again THANK YOU !!!!!
I love Dilly Beans, Dilly Asparagus, Dilly Carrots… Sometimes when I just have a bit of each, I make a jar of each and satisfy my Dilly craving… Same recipe, different veg…
I’ve been using a basic brine recipe for about 3 years which consists of 3parts water to one part vinegar ( typically 3quarts of each ) along with one cup of salt, along with whatever herbs or spices I desired.
I’ve seen in this blog that you’re using equal parts vinegar/water to make your brine, but to me that just tastes too “vinegary”. I’ve never had a problem, but is there a potential safety issue with my brine?
Thanks,
Todd
Todd, there is a potential safety issue with your brine. The USDA says that you should never dilute vinegar by more than half in order to keep the acidity level safe for shelf stability. I’m afraid that your 3 to 1 brine isn’t safe.
Help! Two batches now. One sweet dilly bean, one regular dilly bean. Beans are coming out shrivelled and limp. Had carrots in the second batch, which I liked, but the beans came out looking desiccated. Taste OK, but are like leather. Suggestions?
I wish I had found your recipe before attempting a random one I found on Allrecipes.
My question is about salt: is there a safety problem if you use significantly less, or is it just a taste issue? The recipe I followed called for the same proportion/amount of water/vinegar, but 1 teaspoon of salt in each pint jar. Thanks for any advice!
The salt helps draw out the water in the beans so that it can be replaced by the vinegar brine. It seems that when you use a little bit more salt, you get a crunchier, more pickle-y bean.
So I’m really really new to canning. Tried the black raspberry jam recipe….it rocked. So then I tried a pickled snap pea recipe from a different site… They said to process for 15 min. I ended up with way over cooked, rather gross peas. Fortunately I have a lot left in my garden.
So I was wondering if it is possible to just substitute peas for beans in this recipe and still be safe?
So I’m probably too late on this, but it the processing times depend on how big your peas are, how big your jar is, what the pH of your brine is and how tightly you pack the jars. It sounds complicated, but it’s not really. If you’re using pint jars, most pickles can be safely processed for 8-10 minutes. Beans are especially thin, so you can probably get away with 5. For big fat snap peas, I’d probably do 8 minutes, but it’s worth finding another snap pea pickle recipe to check against. (or even call your local ag extenision office, they are the official word!)
How many jars will this fill?
I finished making a batch of these a few hours ago, and was just wondering if the lids supposed to be raised during the cooling process? Mine already look like they’ve “popped”, but I know they haven’t. This was my first attempt at canning, and I’m paranoid I’ve done something wrong. HELP!
Dawn, the lids should be concave, not raised. One thing that could have happened is that if you tightened the rings too tightly, there may not have been enough space for the air to escape during the cooling process. Raised is definitely not good.
if you overpack the jars the lids raise up to,,,they say you can put them in the fridge and there still good to eat
Man I love your blog, I will be here ateast twice a week.
Loved making these! Wish the green beans in the finished product were green! Mine turned an Army green — is this normal?
That color change is totally normal. That’s what happens when you cook beans.
Just made four pints – they look great! I didn’t have cayenne pepper so I subbed a quarter of a jalepeno per jar. It’s going to be hard to wait 2 weeks to sample! One question, I am always left with extra brine mixture when I follow your pickle recipes. Is this bad? Am I over-filling my jars with veggies? I measure ingredients carefully and always measure the headspace.
Robin, there’s always some leftover brine. It’s really hard to write a recipe that gives you the exact right amount of brine because everyone fills their jars a bit differently. Additionally, it’s better to have a bit too much as opposed to too little, as you wouldn’t want to stop mid-canning to make more brine.
Put up 12 jars of dilly beans last weekend. In half, I substituted tarragon (based on a Sunset Magazine recipe) and tried them for the 1st time last night – terrific! Possible that the leaves will disintegrate over time, but I don’t think the jars will last that long!
I used this recipe and made green bean and wax bean versions. They look beautiful. Can’t wait to taste them. Thanks for the recipe.
Need to know if I did something wrong?? I followed your directions and after i took them out of the canner the beans were at the top of the jar and most of the liquid was on the bottom, ERRRR??????
DOH! I just realized I totally screwed up. The recipe called for 4 cups vinegar, 4 cups water, and 1/2 cup pickling salt. I halved the vinegar and water, but didn’t halve the salt. I was assuming 1/2 cup pickling salt equals 134 grams (something I read on another site). So I should have added half that. Instead I added the full amount. That might explain the puckered beans.
Still, if anyone has solid advice about subbing Diamond Crystal kosher salt for pickling salt, I’d be keen on hearing it. I’m not sure I trust the /2 cup = 134 grams measure. Can anyone confirm or offer advice? Pickling salt is impossible to find in my neighborhood.
Cassie-
If, by chance you still check this site for replies, here is what I can tell you:
There are 28.3 grams to an ounce, and 8 ounces to 1/2 cup. So 1 cup equals 452.8 grams and 1/2 cup equals 226.4 grams. Kosher is not as dense as pickling salt, which is why you need to use more of it. 1 cup of pickling salt would equal 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons of kosher salt. As a good measure, though, it’s always best to measure by weight. That way you KNOW you aren’t over or under-salting your brines! FYI- 134 grams would have been equal to 4 ounces (1/2 cup) of salt.
Hope that helps!
Kristin
Liquid (fluid) ounces are different than solid ounces! You can’t convert a weight to a volume without using the density of the substance.
A quick question. I just used a different recipe to can dilly beans. I subbed kosher salt for pickling salt. So my brine was 2 cups water, 2 cups vinegar and 134 grams kosher salt (maybe a cup?). I think it was nearly double the amount of pickling salt the recipe called for to compensate for the fact that kosher salt is larger grained. I processed the jars for 5 minutes. But now the beans appear to be puckered, with little old-man wrinkles. Too much salt? Too much heat?
How do you keep the beans from floating above the brine level in the jar? Maybe I’m not packing them tight enough?
I made a recipe similair to this, only in each jar i added 1 tsp of crushed red pepper. If you throw 2-3 beans a little of the juice into a bloody mary, its the best thing!!
Elicia, I always raw pack the beans, and I find that they remain perfect for about 6-9 months. They’re still edible after that point, but the texture does start to degrade a little.
is it okay to raw pack the beans? or is hot pack better for longer preservation? i don’t think that i can eat all those beans in three months time…
Michele, I just double-checked and in So Easy to Preserve, the processing time is five minutes. It’s a resource I trust, but if it makes you feel more comfortable, follow the processing time in the Ball Blue Book. However, nothing goes into So Easy to Preserve without being thoroughly tested, so it’s a reliable source.
I saw this same recipe in the Ball Blue Book, but it says to process for 10 minutes. I am confused!
Marisa, i dont know if you got your answers, but 1.the water (actualy brine for dilly beans) goes 1/2inch from rim of jar thats called headspace which the vegetable also goes up to that point as well. 2.The plastic knife (for removing air bubbles is just a safety thing, as you could remotely possibly crack the jar if too vigorous in jamming it down the side of jar with a metal knife ( i did it once) 3. I also believe the rack in pot is important so the jars do not crack from direct contact. It is possible to make a rack by taking enoug extra canning jar lids to line the bottom of the pot placing them right side up(more support, but if the water is bubbling too much they may flip over? also i’ve heard of people laying a folded thick kitchen towel in bottom. Hope this helps you out, good luck…….
I just finish making 7 jars of yellow dilly beans. I’ve been doing this for years and they are a big hit with all my friends and family. They can’t get enough. But I make them different. I use some different spices. I do use fresh yellow beans from my garden and I use fresh dill heads from my garden. The dill heads look very pretty in the jar. I was just on the site because I have been putting my beans in a salted ice water brine for about an hour before I put them into the jars. I do this to maintain the crispness of the bean. But I was wonder if they would no be crisper just directly out of my garden without the salted ice water bath?
Do you think there would be any problem if I used yellow beans??
They will look cooked but will crunch like fresh. Let em soak for a couple of weeks and give em a try
Made my first batch. The finished beans look shriveled. Is that right or did I do something wrong. They were very fresh beans and I only processed for 5 mins. Thanks.
Danie, herby dill breaks down more quickly than dill seeds or heads, which is why it isn’t recommended. However, if you plan on using your dilly beans right away, you can get away with using the frondy stuff.
Shoot, I used herby dill. How quick do I need to be? Thanks,d
Danielle, it’s just a matter of keeping an eye on them. There’s no set time at which the dill will suddenly turn to sludge.
Why isn’t herby dill not recommended?
I always use dill weed in my dilly beans. I let them sit for at least 8 weeks before we eat them. We have jars we pickled last summer that we are just opening. They are great! I have also used chili peppers when I haven’t been able to find cayenne peppers. I use either a whole cayenne pepper or 2 chili peppers. It really depends how spicy you want them. I make some spicy & some not so spicy. The longer they sit the spicier they get.
Marisa, I wonder what I could have done wrong with the recipe. My brine ended up being overly salty even though I only used 1/4 cup. Other than that, these are lovely. The texture is crispy and snappy.
Thank you for this! My garden is full of green beans — and each time I have a plethora of something, you seem to have an appropriate recipe. Thanks for reading my mind.
Aha! Perfect. I shall make these forthright!
One thing I recently learned about these pickles is that if you’re planning on making them to be refrigerator pickles, make sure to reduce the salt. Without the hot water process, they can be overly salty. Just a word to the wise!
Sorry for the confusion, Dan. I learned after I made my pickles that it was not recommended to use herby dill. I didn’t have a chance to go back and make another batch, but I wanted to give the most up-to-date information I had.
In the picture it looks like there is herby dill in the jars. Lefthand jar, bottom side, and the righthand jar on the left.
The recipe specifically says not to use the herby dill..
Am I missing something?
I made dilly beans for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I’ve never had them so I’m really excited to see how they taste.
I have some pretty dumb questions about canning, and I’m wondering if you have a photo essay somewhere, kind of a basic how-to. If not, may I suggest one? I think getting a visual would help me a lot. My main questions (today, anyway) are: how far up the side of the canning jars does the water go; and why a plastic knife to let out the air? I assume it’s a metal + vinegar = bad thing, but am not sure.
Also, how necessary is a rack, really? I have a deep pot but don’t want to explode something if I put jars in there and it’s a bad idea.
Thanks for the post – I’ve got a photocopy of a hand-written dilly bean recipe that I’ve wanted to try but have been too unsure about the basics of canning.
Perhaps it’ll be my first attempt!
Beth, I don’t have a photo-essay like you’re talking about, but I’ve been meaning to do one. I will try to get it done soon, thanks for the reminder! -Marisa
if you don’t have a rack for your pot, a folded up kitchen towel will protect the bottoms of your jars from getting too much direct heat.
Wendi, these make a fine refrigerator pickle, if you don’t want to process them in the boiling water. If that’s the case, you don’t even have to heat the brine. Just make sure you give them at least a few days in the fridge to really soak up the brine.
MrsCatbird, the things we do for love! 😉
Jenn FL, you should make a batch!
My mother used to make these!! They were always my favourite!!
I so thoroughly relate to the cooking for love thing. For the first couple of years of our cohabitation, I would always whip up meat and potatoes dishes for my husband. Only recently have I really started to move more into foods that I love, that he’ll at least eat, like your lovely sounding string bean meal.
Would these be ok to make even without the boiling water bath? More like a refrigerator pickle? I’ve had great success with pickled carrots and think green beans would be a nice change.